The name of this recipe, Salted Caramel Apple Butter, tells you everything you need to know about it. This will be your new fave.
As far as I’m concerned, you can’t have too many recipes that have apples as the main ingredient. Not kidding. If you gave me 10 bushels of apples, I’d find a way to use every single one. (Except the ones with worm holes!)
I’d definitely make Snickers Apple Salad. Have you tried it? If not, you must. It’s easy and such a good, quick recipe for a get-together. For sure Mason Jar Lid Mini Apple Pies is another. They’re so cute, it’s almost ridiculous!
Salted Caramel Apple Butter
I’m always surprised at how many people have never tried apple butter. Have you? If not, you don’t know what you’re missing.
Think of it as applesauce that’s thick and rich and smooth and super flavorful.
We use regular apple butter on toast and biscuits. But this particular recipe? I have to say that Salted Caramel Apple Butter kicks it up a notch. Maybe 10 notches, now that I think of it.
Serving Salted Caramel Apple Butter
The next time you’re planning any sort of dessert bar, a few pretty glass containers of this stuff and you open up a whole new way to think about dessert.
I suggest chunks of plain pound cake to spread it on. You might even want to toast some.
You should also try some plain scones, and what about some churros? Oh my gosh, y’all. Doesn’t that sound amazing?
This is also great to put in Jars for gifts. We used 4 oz glass jars with lids.
The caramel sauce is everything.
Wait until you taste this! Warm, homemade caramel sauce is (in my opinion) the twist in this recipe that makes it exceptionally good.
Made with maple syrup, brown sugar, and unsalted butter, it makes these little pots of apple gold good to the last spoonful.
Want to pick your own apples?
If it’s apple picking time where you are, but you aren’t sure where to go, this may help. Visit 29 Best Apple Picking Farms and Orchards Across the Country. It’s a great resource.
Notes…
I am sure this apple butter can easily be preserved and canned using the hot water bath method, though I have no tried this yet myself.
Salted Caramel Apple Butter
Ingredients
Ingredients:
Apple Butter Ingredients:
Caramel Ingredients:
- 1 TBSP unsalted butter
- 1 TBSP packed brown sugar
- 1 TBSP maple syrup
- 1/4 tsp sea salt
- 1 TBSP heavy cream
- Slow cooker
- Food processor
- heavy skillet
- whisk
Instructions
Directions:
Apple Butter Directions:
- Prep the slow cooker with a coat of cooking spray.
- Add the apples, apple juice, and all of the spices in the slow cooker.
- Put on the lid.
- Turn on high cooking for an hour.
- Turn off the cooker.
- Add a third of the stewed apple mixture to the food processor or use a immersion blender. Continue to blend until the apples are smooth.
- Repeat the process until all of the stewed apples are blended.
- Pour the mixture back in the in the slow cooker.
- Turn the slow cooker on low and continue to cook for 6-8 hours. (The apple mixture will be about half of what it was.) Set aside.
Caramel Sauce Directions:
- Add the maple syrup, butter, and brown sugar in the skillet and cook on medium to high heat.
- Begin to whisk the butter, syrup, and brown sugar continuing until the mixture has thicken and is bubbly.
- Continue whisking while adding the salt and heavy cream. (1-2 minutes) Remove from the heat.
- Slowly stir in caramel sauce to the apple mixture.
- Set aside to allow to cool.
- Scoop into 4 oz lidded jars.
Last Step:
Please leave a rating and comment letting us know how you liked this recipe! This helps our business to thrive and continue providing free, high-quality recipes for you.Nutrition
Leave a Review!
We LOVE hearing from you! Submit your question or comment here.
Your email address will not be published.
89 comments on “Salted Caramel Apple Butter”
how many 4 oz jars does this yield?
Hi Polly. About 7 jars.
I want to try this but was reading the ingredients…. the amounts on the caramel portion just dont seem right to me… only a little over 4 tbsp (tablespoons) of ingredients? Help please!
Hi Melissa, Yes, those are the correct amounts.
Made this for xmas gifts. It was very tasty. I used my electric pressure cooker for 35 minutes, but it was still too thin, I just simmered for a while until it thickened. Very delicious! Thanks for posting!
Also, side note to those of you who might be worried about canning this due to the dairy, I used Country Crock plant based butter and plant heavy cream. Both of those are by Country Crock and they’re absolutely delicious.
This is absolutely delicious my family loves this
Thank you for posting this recipe. It looks GREAT! I can’t believe the number of comments below asking questions that you answered in your recipe/procedure! Don’t people know how to read anymore!!??
This was really good, although I did add a small amount of brown sugar because I used a variety of apples that weren’t very sweet. It was hard to be patient while it cooked down, because mine took closer to 10 hours to get to the proper consistency.
If you use hot jars and lids and twist the ban on tightly they will seal and pop without the hot bath.
If you make this recipe as posted, what is the shelf life?
Thanks!
I made this and it had excellent flavor! However I never got it to thicken. It was more like applesauce. Any idea what I did wrong?
This recipe is easy and fabulous! Really tasty, will be freezing some of mine and then defrost and put into small Kilmer jars for gifts for Christmas ! Thank you !!!
This can not be processed in a water bath canner, as dairy and butter are not on the safe list.. but sounds yummy !Â
The apples will keep the pH low enough to be safe.
If you’re concerned about that then just plant based heavy cream and butter.
Absolutely delicious! Only thing that I did differently was I cooked the apples in my Instant Pot pressure cooker for 20 minutes rather than using a slow cooker. I did the caramel on the stove top as directed , used my immersion blender for the apples then added the caramel!
Did you still cook the apple mixture for the 6 to 8 hours after putting thru the food processor?
I cooked mine in my electric pressure cooker for 35 min and then have had it on slow cook for hours now, but it’s still too thin?
Absolutely delicious! Only thing that I did differently was I cooked the apples in my Instant Pot pressure cooker for 20 minutes rather than using a slow cooker. I did the caramel on the stove top as directed , used my immersion blender for the apples then added the caramel!