Classic Monster Nutter Butter Cookies

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read our disclosure policy.
Classic Monster Nutter Butter Cookies

We love making classic monsters into food & had a blast making these Classic Monster Nutter Butter Cookies!  We decorated these using assorted candies that we had on hand & my boys loved them!  Easy to make and a fun Halloween treat for the kids to decorate themselves!

Classic Monster Nutter Butter Cookies

(makes 4)

4 Nutter Butter’s

Chocolate & White Cookie Icing (Betty Crocker)

Edible Eyes

Assorted Candies (Tootsie Rolls, Mini M&M’s, Sprinkles,etc…)

Dracula Nutter Butter's

Dracula Nutter Butter’s

You want to cover the front of the cookie withe the white cookie icing.  Then cover the top and bottom with the chocolate cookie icing in the shape of his hair & cape.  Use a toothpick to help direct the icing before it sets.  We cut a piece of a red fruit roll up for the mouth. We used heart candies for the bow tie, cut a piece from a Tootsie Roll for eyebrows, cut a mini marshmallow for the nose & teeth.

Mummy Nutter Butter's

Mummy Nutter Butter’s

We covered the cookie with white cookie icing.  We cut strips from a square marshmallow and laid them on top. We cut a piece from a Tootsie Roll for the top and attached on edible eyes.

Frankenutter Butter's

Frankenutter Butter’s

We covered the cookie with white cookie icing & the top with chocolate cookie icing.  We cut pieces from a green Tootsie Roll to make the mouth, nose & eye brows. We attached on green M&M’s for the electrodes.

Wolf Man Nutter Butter's

Wolf Man Nutter Butter’s

We covered the cookie with chocolate cookie icing.  We used a toothpick to make it look like fur.  We cut pieces from a Tootsie Roll for the eye brows & nose.  We cut a mini marshmallow for teeth.

You can view all of our other Halloween fun food creations HERE!

Leave a Review!

We LOVE hearing from you! Submit your question or comment here.

Your email address will not be published.

Your email address will not be published.

I accept the Privacy Policy

7 comments on “Classic Monster Nutter Butter Cookies”

  1. Brenda @ SweetSimpleStuff

    Outstanding! I've seen many mummies … yours is the best! I must have missed these … just saw them over on Hungry Happenings!

  2. Scarlett @Scarletts Excellent Adventures

    So, so, so cute! This might be a little advanced for me, but I'm pinning anyway!

Scroll to Top