Easy Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Turkey Cookies

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read our disclosure policy.
Reese's Turkey Cookies that the kids can help make themselves!

I am the room mom this year for my older sons 4th grade class & totally forgot that I needed to make the kids some treats for Thanksgiving until later this afternoon. I needed something quick & easy! We are always loaded up on Keebler & Hershey products so we created these fun Reese’s Turkey Cookies!

We spotted turkey cookies from Bake at 350 & loved them. That’s what inspired us to make these cute little guys. I didn’t have time to mess with coloring frosting, baking, etc..plus I have little helping hands & didn’t want a mess. These are great cookies to get the kids to help with themselves & they will love separating the colored M&M’s as well!

Easy Reese’s Turkey Cookies

Keebler Butter Cookies
Reese’s Mini Peanut Butter Cups
Hershey’s Mini M&M’s
Jet-Puffed Mallobits
Black Edible Marker
Chocolate Cookie Frosting (Betty Crocker)
Red Sprinkles

Start out by cutting the mallobits in half with a knife & press a black edible marker in the middle. We came up with this years ago & I use these eyes for lots of our fun food creations! A cheap way to make little edible eyes. Have the kids separate the yellow, orange. & red mini M&M’s in 3 separate bowls. Take a hand full of the orange M&M’s & cut them in half. Take the chocolate cookie frosting & make 3 lines on the top. Add a strip of red at the top..then orange in the middle..then yellow at the bottom. Attach the peanut butter cup on the with frosting as well. We used the orange M&M’s halves for the feet & beak. We used a red sprinkle for the wattle. Let them dry & that’s it!!

We made 24 of them & I think the kids will love them tomorrow!

Easy Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Turkey Cookies

Here is a close up…

Easy Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Turkey Cookies

Check out the Turkey Cookies from Bake at 350 that inspired us to make these…..

Turkey Cookies from Bake at 350

You can view all of our other fun food Thanksgiving ideas HERE!

Leave a Review!

We LOVE hearing from you! Submit your question or comment here.

Your email address will not be published.

Your email address will not be published.

I accept the Privacy Policy

7 comments on “Easy Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Turkey Cookies”

  1. Beth Jackson Klosterboer

    So cute. I like that you used M&M's for the feathers and the beak. I bet the kids loved them!

    Beth @ Hungry Happenings

  2. I am surprised with all the the allergies you can still bring peanut butter into school. They look very cute but we could never bring cookies let alone PB>

    1. Thanks…our school goes by the class. There is no one in my sons 4th grade class with allergies. If there was…I would use a different candy for them.

Scroll to Top